Codex Tenebrae 2011

Fuente Anejo #46	$12	Med	A+	Ultimate in savory maduro bliss
Camacho Triple Maduro	$13	Full	A+	Ultimate in peppery maduro bliss
Perdomo ESV 1991	$9	Full	A	Great blend and rich maduro flavor
Alec Bradley Black Market	$9	Solid Medium	A	Great maduro flavor, body, with good price
J. Fuego Delirium	$9	Med	A	Mmmmmaaaadurooohhh
Carlos Toraño Virtuoso	$9	Med+	A	Good smoke, attractive
Joya de Nicaragua Antaño 1970	$7	Full	A	Hold on to your pants.
Perdomo 10th Anniversary Reserve maduro	$9	Med	A-	Wow. A great follow-up from the original Perdomo Reserve series.
Carlos Toraño Signature	$6	Med	A-	Great smoke, score when possible
Graycliff 1666	$8	Med+	A-	Delicious
Savinelli Rico y Raro	$8	Full+	A-	Great tasting smoke, big nicotine hit. 2+ whole leaves of ligero per cigar.
Perdomo Habano	$6	Med	B+	Good smoke, great price.
Padron Anniversary 1964 maduro	$14	Med+	B+	Smooth earth, coffee, cocoa flavors, w/ a little spice. Expected more for the $$.
Panacea Green maduro	$6	Med	B+	Earth, leather and spide at the end, nice bang for the buck
San Cristobal	$9	Med	B+	Nice Pepin blend, but not big on maduro flavor
CAO Brazilia	$7	Med	B+	Spicy and well blended
Camacho SLR maduro	$7	Full	B+	Like getting hit in the mouth with a cedar 2x4 wrapped in leather and sprinkled in cocoa.
CAO Italia	$7	Med	B+	Spicy, but with a little tang to it
Oliva Serie O	$6	Med	B	Another good smoke with a great price
Avo #2 maduro	$8	Mild+	B	Nutty, creamy blend dusted with cocoa
Panacea Black Classic	$6	Med	B	Leathery, with some earth, but little spice.
Padron 3000	$6	Med	B	Muscular flavors, good maduro
Oliva Serie G	$5	Mild+	B	Nice smoke, always a pleasure
Hoyo de Monterrey Excalibur Dark Knight	$5	Med	B	Solid, dependable smoke
Romeo y Julieta Reserve Maduro	$5	Med-	B	Nice blend, but a little on the mild side
Camacho Corojo	$7	Med	B	Corojo heat, maduro sweet
Carlos Toraño Exodus 1959	$6	Med	B	Good smoke
La Gloria Cubana Serie R	$7	Full	B	Good smoke, with kick
Alec Bradley Maxx	$5	Med-	B	Nice smoke, fat and cool
CAO MX2	$7	Med	B	Good maduro flavors, unusual blend
Macanudo 1968	$10	Med	B	Good smoke, but overpriced
Rocky Patel Edge Missile	$6	Med+	B	Good go-to stick
Perdomo Reserve Maduro	$5	Med	B	Great blend, rich maduro flavor
Savinelli Nicaraguan Reserve	$6	Med+	B	Unexpected, great smoke, spices, coffee, cocoa. Could be lovechild of Oliva O and Perdomo Reserve.
Perdomo Lot 23	$4	Mild+	B-	Nice smoke at reasonable price
Hoyo de Monterrey Dark Sumatra	$5	Med	B-	Nice blend, but faint maduro flavors
Gurkha Legend "8-year Aged"	$6	Med-	B-	Good smoke, but not much maduro flavor
Arturo Fuente Chateau	$5	Mild+	B-	Nice blend, but faint maduro flavors
Partagas Black	$6	Med	B-	Peppery blend, more coffee and cedar than cocoa
C&C LRMD Maduro	$6	Mild	B-	Mild earth and leather flavors; a rookie's maduro
CAO L'Anniversaire Maduro	$7.50	Med	B-	Nice maduro flavors, but overpriced
5 Vegas Series A	$3	Med-	B-	Great blend and smoke for the price
Cusano 18 Paired Maduro	$5	Mild+	C+	Mild blend with spunk, soft maduro flavor
Indian Tabac Cameroon Legend	$4	Med-	C+	Fat, cool smoke, mild maduro tone
Hoyo de Monterrey maduro	$4	Med-	C+	Nice smoke at reasonable price
Sancho Panza Double Maduro	$4	Mild+	C+	Nice maduro flavor
Flor de Oliva maduro	$2	Med-	C+	Budget smoke with a little maduro touch
La Vieja Habana Belicoso D	$3	Med-	C+	Nice budget maduro
Occidental Reserve Double Broadleaf	$3	Mild	C	Good starter maduro
Carlos Toraño Exodus 1959 Silver	$5	Med-	C	Nice blend, but tend to explode
Punch Maduro Maduro	$5	Med-	C	Solid smoke, decent maduro flavor
Gurkha Doble Maduro	$5	Med-	C	Starts off great, tasting like Partagas Black, but gets bland after the first third.
Don Pepin Garcia Series JJ	$7	Med	C	Nice blend, but little maduro flavor
Padron 2000	$5	Med	C	Good cigar for the price
Omar Ortez maduro	$5	Med	C	Decent smoke
Chateau Real maduro	$6	Mild+	C	Not bad, but you can get better for the $
Drew Estates Dirt	$5	Med-	C	Oddball flavor, sweetened cap
Sol Cubano maduro	$2	Med-	C	Nice value smoke
Alec Bradley Ovation	$3	Mild+	C	Not bad. Not great, but not bad.
Arganese Chairman	$5	Med-	C	Decent smoke, but mild maduro flavor
Helix 550 tubo	$4	Mild	C-	Airy, with little maduro flavor
Padilla Obsidian	$4	Med-	C-	Great taste, but very inconsistent construction
Muira maduro	$4	Med	C-	So-so, wrapper may be dyed
Angel 100	$3	Mild+	C-	Eh
Pirate's Gold maduro	$1	Mild+	D	The name is the only redeeming value
Cu-Avana maduro	$2	Mild	D	Like smoking wheat toast
Rio del Pinar "oscuro"	$3	Med-	D	Nothing oscuro about this yard 'gar
Rocky Patel R4	$4	Med-	D	Wrapper tasted super-salty/chemically
Victor Sinclair Reserve	$4	Med-	D	I smoked it out of kindness. Never again
Tierra del Sol maduro	$2	Mild+	D	Avoid. A. V. O. I. D.
Nestor Reserve 2004	$2	Mild+	F	Dyed wrapper covers crummy blend