Codex Tenebrae 2011

Fuente Anejo #46	$12	Med	A+	Ultimate in savory maduro bliss
Camacho Triple Maduro	$13	Full	A+	Ultimate in peppery maduro bliss
Perdomo ESV 1991	$9	Full	A	Great blend and rich maduro flavor
Alec Bradley Black Market	$9	Solid Medium	A	Great maduro flavor, body, with good price
J. Fuego Delirium	$9	Med	A	Mmmmmaaaadurooohhh
Carlos Toraño Virtuoso	$9	Med+	A	Good smoke, attractive
Joya de Nicaragua Antaño 1970	$7	Full	A	Hold on to your pants.
Perdomo 10th Anniversary Reserve maduro	$9	Med	A-	Wow. A great follow-up from the original Perdomo Reserve series.
Carlos Toraño Signature	$6	Med	A-	Great smoke, score when possible
Graycliff 1666	$8	Med+	A-	Delicious
Savinelli Rico y Raro	$8	Full+	A-	Great tasting smoke, big nicotine hit. 2+ whole leaves of ligero per cigar.
Perdomo Habano	$6	Med	B+	Good smoke, great price.
Padron Anniversary 1964 maduro	$14	Med+	B+	Smooth earth, coffee, cocoa flavors, w/ a little spice. Expected more for the $$.
Panacea Green maduro	$6	Med	B+	Earth, leather and spide at the end, nice bang for the buck
San Cristobal	$9	Med	B+	Nice Pepin blend, but not big on maduro flavor
CAO Brazilia	$7	Med	B+	Spicy and well blended
Camacho SLR maduro	$7	Full	B+	Like getting hit in the mouth with a cedar 2x4 wrapped in leather and sprinkled in cocoa.
CAO Italia	$7	Med	B+	Spicy, but with a little tang to it
Oliva Serie O	$6	Med	B	Another good smoke with a great price
Avo #2 maduro	$8	Mild+	B	Nutty, creamy blend dusted with cocoa
Panacea Black Classic	$6	Med	B	Leathery, with some earth, but little spice.
Padron 3000	$6	Med	B	Muscular flavors, good maduro
Oliva Serie G	$5	Mild+	B	Nice smoke, always a pleasure
Hoyo de Monterrey Excalibur Dark Knight	$5	Med	B	Solid, dependable smoke
Romeo y Julieta Reserve Maduro	$5	Med-	B	Nice blend, but a little on the mild side
Camacho Corojo	$7	Med	B	Corojo heat, maduro sweet
Carlos Toraño Exodus 1959	$6	Med	B	Good smoke
La Gloria Cubana Serie R	$7	Full	B	Good smoke, with kick
Alec Bradley Maxx	$5	Med-	B	Nice smoke, fat and cool
CAO MX2	$7	Med	B	Good maduro flavors, unusual blend
Macanudo 1968	$10	Med	B	Good smoke, but overpriced
Rocky Patel Edge Missile	$6	Med+	B	Good go-to stick
Perdomo Reserve Maduro	$5	Med	B	Great blend, rich maduro flavor
Savinelli Nicaraguan Reserve	$6	Med+	B	Unexpected, great smoke, spices, coffee, cocoa. Could be lovechild of Oliva O and Perdomo Reserve.
Perdomo Lot 23	$4	Mild+	B-	Nice smoke at reasonable price
Hoyo de Monterrey Dark Sumatra	$5	Med	B-	Nice blend, but faint maduro flavors
Gurkha Legend "8-year Aged"	$6	Med-	B-	Good smoke, but not much maduro flavor
Arturo Fuente Chateau	$5	Mild+	B-	Nice blend, but faint maduro flavors
Partagas Black	$6	Med	B-	Peppery blend, more coffee and cedar than cocoa
C&C LRMD Maduro	$6	Mild	B-	Mild earth and leather flavors; a rookie's maduro
CAO L'Anniversaire Maduro	$7.50	Med	B-	Nice maduro flavors, but overpriced
5 Vegas Series A	$3	Med-	B-	Great blend and smoke for the price
Cusano 18 Paired Maduro	$5	Mild+	C+	Mild blend with spunk, soft maduro flavor
Indian Tabac Cameroon Legend	$4	Med-	C+	Fat, cool smoke, mild maduro tone
Hoyo de Monterrey maduro	$4	Med-	C+	Nice smoke at reasonable price
Sancho Panza Double Maduro	$4	Mild+	C+	Nice maduro flavor
Flor de Oliva maduro	$2	Med-	C+	Budget smoke with a little maduro touch
La Vieja Habana Belicoso D	$3	Med-	C+	Nice budget maduro
Occidental Reserve Double Broadleaf	$3	Mild	C	Good starter maduro
Carlos Toraño Exodus 1959 Silver	$5	Med-	C	Nice blend, but tend to explode
Punch Maduro Maduro	$5	Med-	C	Solid smoke, decent maduro flavor
Gurkha Doble Maduro	$5	Med-	C	Starts off great, tasting like Partagas Black, but gets bland after the first third.
Don Pepin Garcia Series JJ	$7	Med	C	Nice blend, but little maduro flavor
Padron 2000	$5	Med	C	Good cigar for the price
Omar Ortez maduro	$5	Med	C	Decent smoke
Chateau Real maduro	$6	Mild+	C	Not bad, but you can get better for the $
Drew Estates Dirt	$5	Med-	C	Oddball flavor, sweetened cap
Sol Cubano maduro	$2	Med-	C	Nice value smoke
Alec Bradley Ovation	$3	Mild+	C	Not bad. Not great, but not bad.
Arganese Chairman	$5	Med-	C	Decent smoke, but mild maduro flavor
Helix 550 tubo	$4	Mild	C-	Airy, with little maduro flavor
Padilla Obsidian	$4	Med-	C-	Great taste, but very inconsistent construction
Muira maduro	$4	Med	C-	So-so, wrapper may be dyed
Angel 100	$3	Mild+	C-	Eh
Pirate's Gold maduro	$1	Mild+	D	The name is the only redeeming value
Cu-Avana maduro	$2	Mild	D	Like smoking wheat toast
Rio del Pinar "oscuro"	$3	Med-	D	Nothing oscuro about this yard 'gar
Rocky Patel R4	$4	Med-	D	Wrapper tasted super-salty/chemically
Victor Sinclair Reserve	$4	Med-	D	I smoked it out of kindness. Never again
Tierra del Sol maduro	$2	Mild+	D	Avoid. A. V. O. I. D.
Nestor Reserve 2004	$2	Mild+	F	Dyed wrapper covers crummy blend

Getting My Way: Panacea Cigars

Sometimes, it takes a bit of persuasion to get a shop owner to carry a cigar that is from a smaller, less renowned company. Not that you can blame them, they already have to cater to a number of whims, and inventory that just sits for a loooong time doesn't really help the shop owner. A guy has to be judicious with his humidor space.

After the Christmas cigar bomb I got from my mother, I started agitating at a local shop to pick up Panacea cigars (by Flatbed Cigar Co., out of eastern PA). None of the shops in town carried them, and I've started buying most of my cigars from local shops. So, if I wanted Panacea, I'd have to convince one of the local shops to pick them up. It took a lot of casual "did you call them yet," and "have you heard from them (I gave them your phone number and address)." I'm sure he got tired of hearing about it, every other visit I'd try and subtly nudge him along.

9 months after the first mention,the shop owner got a bunch of samples in from Flatbed, and had me assemble a puffin' posse to smoke and grade the different samples. I started an 'Event' on Facebook, and invited all my local cigar friends and acquaintances, and on the night of the event, we had 6 fairly experienced cigar enthusiasts gathered to have a go at the Panacea cigars.

The shop owner had printed out info from Flatbed's web site on all the different cigars, and so we each grabbed a cigar that was generally suited to our preferences and started firing them up. Two hours of smoky conversation and comparison ensued, talking about flavors, burn, draw, ash and the advantages of target shooting with a .223 over larger calibers. The whole gamut, you know. Good conversation with friends, and decent coffee, is always a great companion for a cigar.

I had previously smoked, and thoroughly enjoyed, the Red label Habano maduro and Black label maduro. So, I started with the Green label maduro, and PA Broadleaf wrapped cigar; YUMMM!!! Nicely earthy and dark flavors, but was lacking spice until you got to the last third of the cigar, when it finally sauntered in.

The Blue label Grande 6x60 got mixed reviews from the two folks smoking them, for uneven draw and unexpected flavors. The Red label Grande was liked by the folks smoking them, as were the Black label natural and maduro that another pair were enjoying. The lone person smoking the White label Corojo had some extreme wrapper failure going on, so that got panned in the evaluation [I smoked the other White label Corojo the week after, and it was perfect, so better luck next time].

After we were done with our casual evaluations, the shop owner ordered the top 3 lines we recommended. Eventually, should these start selling well, we'll be able to look at a couple lines that ended up a little farther down the list. I liked the White label Corojo, once I got a chance to smoke one. At the end of the day, I got this shop to get on board with a cigar I liked. So, win for me, and I hope it's a win for the shop in the long run as well.